Early-stage MedTechs: Hire for experience or for “cultural fit”?

We’re answering one of the talent-related questions that has come up in a few of our MedTech CEO-Only Events. When interviewing potential hires, should you hire for experience or cultural fit? As with most topics, there is no black-and-white answer, but don’t worry—we’ve got some insights to help you navigate the complexities of building your startup team.

You’re in the early stages of building your company. You need people who know the ropes, but you also need a team of people who trust each other and navigate conflict well. So, what should you prioritize?

Why Experience Matters:

Experienced hires bring a deep understanding of the MedTech industry, including regulatory requirements, technical challenges, and market dynamics. This expertise can be invaluable, especially in navigating complex product development pathways and regulatory landscapes, which can only be learned with experience.

Seasoned professionals often have a track record of success and can hit the ground running. They bring a wealth of skills and insights honed over years of working in the field, which can accelerate your startup's growth and reduce the learning curve.

Moreover, senior professionals typically have extensive networks within the industry. These connections can open doors to partnerships, funding opportunities, and collaborations, providing your startup with strategic advantages and resource access.

The Power of Cultural Fit:

Cultural fit refers to how well an individual aligns with the values, norms, and behaviors of your startup's culture. Hiring for cultural fit can foster a cohesive and collaborative work environment where team members trust each other and work well together.

Employees who resonate with your startup's mission and values are more likely to be motivated and committed to its success. This alignment can drive innovation, enhance productivity, and create a positive work culture that attracts and retains talent.

Additionally, cultural fit contributes to employee satisfaction and retention. When employees feel they belong and their values align with the company's values, they are more likely to stay long-term and adapt positively to organizational changes and challenges.

Finding the Sweet Spot:

So, how do you get the best of both worlds? Here are a few tips:

• Set rigorous minimum expectations for relevant experience, and avoid defining this in “years”, as more years does not necessarily translate to more relevant experience (and the inverse is also true: fewer years does not mean less relevant experience).
• Plan your interviews to combine structured and unstructured elements to assess candidates' abilities and fit into your startup's culture. Ask questions about how the candidate has handled difficult situations in the past. If possible, ask for a reference to corroborate what they tell you.
• Implement a robust onboarding process to integrate new hires effectively into your startup's culture. Provide opportunities for them to understand your company's values, norms, and expectations and foster an environment where they feel supported and motivated from day one.
• Beware of potential hires who are overly enthusiastic right off the bat. Those who ask insightful questions and really want to understand the technology and how it fits into the broader healthcare landscape before showing enthusiasm are generally more genuinely excited.

Ultimately, hiring for experience or cultural fit should align with your startup's strategic goals, growth stage, and organizational culture. By carefully considering both factors in your hiring process, you can build a cohesive and high-performing team that drives innovation, achieves milestones, and propels your early-stage MedTech startup toward success.

As we mentioned in the beginning, there is no clear black-and-white answer. Often, particularly in the early stages of a MedTech startup, it can be challenging to identify exactly what you should be looking for and to design a process that yields the right hire. For critical hires, engaging a recruitment firm can help you clarify your needs based on what is really out in the candidate market, identify the right candidates to fill those needs, and, more importantly, design an educational hiring process that empowers both you and candidates to find the right fit. For example, we are frequently approached by early-stage founders in search of a CEO because they feel they cannot or are unwilling to raise capital. In these cases, hiring an outside CEO can be an expensive mistake - early-stage investors generally want to interact with the founders who know the problem and product inside and out. A savvier approach would be to identify and onboard an experienced independent board member who can provide sage guidance to early-stage founders and add credibility when interacting with investors. 

Navigating the early-stage MedTech Startup journey is challenging, but you're not alone. Lifeblood's team of current and former MedTech CEOs, physicians, and recruiters is here to help guide you toward success. If you're considering your next hire, contact us at Lifeblood.com.

‍